Round #592

09 May 2026, 23:21· hr-law· Meta-Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct· r13-clean-hints
Complexity
band 0
ZP / UO / OBS
0 / 0 / 0
Journey weight
0
Lightshift ΔL

Prompt

I bought a kettle that broke after 3 weeks. Am I entitled to a refund under UK consumer law?

Zero-point index (what the engine surfaced)

ZPI-ZPI-0001 | 2026-05-09T23:21:07Z I bought a kettle that broke after 3 weeks. Am I entitled to a refund under UK consumer law? ZERO POINT — 0 entries (structural invariants) UNOBSERVED — 0 entries (implied truths) OBSERVED — 0 entries (explicit in request) COMPLEXITY │ 0 entries │ spread: 0° │ band: LOW

Baseline response (no ZPI)

Under UK consumer law, you may be entitled to a refund or a replacement for your kettle, depending on the circumstances. Here's a breakdown of your rights: 1. **Sale of Goods Act 1979**: This law states that goods must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose, and match their description. Since your kettle broke after only 3 weeks, it's likely that it didn't meet these standards. 2. **Consumer Rights Act 2015**: This law replaced the Sale of Goods Act for consumer contracts. It states that goods must be: * Of satisfactory quality * Fit for purpose * Match their description * Comply with any sample or model shown * Comply with any public statements made about the goods (e.g., advertising claims) Given that your kettle broke after a short period, you can argue that it's not of satisfactory quality. **Your rights:** * **Within 30 days**: You have the right to reject the goods and request a full refund. This is known as the "short-term right to reject." * **After 30 days but within 6 months**: If you're outside the initial 30-day period, you can request a repair or replacement. If the repair or replacement is not possible or is unsuccessful, you may be entitled to a refund or a price reduction. * **After 6 months**: You'll need to prove that the fault was present at the time of purchase. You may still be entitled to a repair, replacement, or refund, but the burden of proof is on you. **What to do:** 1. **Contact the seller**: Reach out to the retailer where you purchased the kettle and explain the situation. Provide proof of purchase and a clear description of the fault. 2. **Request a refund or replacement**: Depending on the circumstances, you can ask for a refund, replacement, or repair. 3. **If the seller refuses**: You can contact the manufacturer or seek advice from a consumer protection organization, such as Citizens Advice or the Consumer Ombudsman. Remember to keep records of your correspondence and any evidence of the fault, as this will help support your claim. I hope this helps, and you're able to resolve the issue with your kettle!

Enhanced response (with ZPI)

Under UK consumer law, you may be entitled to a refund or replacement for your kettle. The Consumer Rights Act 2015 states that goods must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose, and match the description. Given that your kettle broke after only 3 weeks, it's likely that it did not meet the satisfactory quality requirement. You can claim a refund or replacement from the seller, provided you act quickly. Here are the general steps to follow: 1. **Check your receipt and warranty**: Verify the purchase date, price, and any warranty or guarantee that came with the kettle. 2. **Contact the seller**: Reach out to the seller, explaining the issue and providing proof of purchase. They may offer a refund, replacement, or repair. 3. **Cite the Consumer Rights Act 2015**: Inform the seller that you're making a claim under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, as the kettle did not meet the satisfactory quality requirement. 4. **Provide evidence**: Offer to provide photos or videos of the faulty kettle, as well as any relevant documentation, such as the receipt and warranty. 5. **Seek a refund or replacement**: If the seller agrees that the kettle is faulty, ask for a refund or replacement. You may also be entitled to compensation for any reasonable costs incurred, such as postage or travel expenses. Keep in mind that the seller may try to repair the kettle instead of replacing it. However, if you're not satisfied with the repair or if the kettle is no longer available, you can request a refund. It's essential to act quickly, as your rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 are time-limited. You typically have 30 days to reject the goods and claim a full refund. After this period, you may still be entitled to a repair or replacement, but the seller may not be obligated to provide a refund. If the seller refuses to help or you're not satisfied with their response, you can contact the Citizens Advice Consumer Service or seek advice from a consumer protection organization, such as Trading Standards.

Grader chain

Each grader reads the same baseline + enhanced pair and casts an independent verdict. Disagreement is the framework's own signal — not noise to be averaged away.

V1samba/Meta-Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
Better
V4qwen2.5-coder-3b-instruct
Better
V5openrouter/qwen/qwen3-235b-a22b-2507
Same
V7qwen2.5-coder-7b-instruct
Better
V8openai/gpt-4.1
Same
V9anthropic/claude-opus-4-7
Worse
V12openai/gpt-4o
Same

Comments

Our grader said what it said. What do you say? Comment as a guest below.

No comments yet. Be the first to say what you make of this round.

← back to all rounds